Their earlier concept holds that when change in evaluation or attitude takes place, it always increases congruity with respect. An interpretative phenomenological analysis ipa methodology was used to capture the first person, aslived experience of these utah women leaders. It was developed by charles osgood and percy tannenbaum to improve on the first consistency theory, fritz heiders balance theory. Selfconcept congruity in the light of the theory, research. Congruity theory also has some unexpected advantages. When gender is salient, assertive women will lack in. Congruity argument for god, from the great doctrines of the. Testing the effects of congruity, travel constraints, and. Bower, monteiro, and gilligan 1978, however, reported an increased mood congruity recall effect for men. Merge pdf files combine pdfs in the order you want with the easiest pdf merger available. This is exactly the kind of situation that persuasion studies. Second, rarely has intersectional theory been tested in nonwestern settings. Prologue to a unified theory of attitudes, stereotypes, and.
Review of evidence for implicit consistency in social. The principle of congruity in the analysis of international business cooperation 1. Role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders. A role congruity theory of candidate electability in transitional tunisia volume issue 1 lindsay j. Our findings help to extend role congruity theory by demonstrating how it can be supplemented based on other theories in the literature, as well as how the theory can be applied to both female and male leaders. Pdf purpose the purpose of this paper is to test the impact of symbolic and. To change the order of your pdfs, drag and drop the files as you want. A role congruity bias explanation for this phenomenon in the community college setting was examined.
The role of value congruity and consumer brand identification toward development of brand commitment and positive word of mouth yohana larasati and arga hananto department of management, universitas indonesia introduction intense business competition require companies must work harder to get and retain customers. As a result, incongruity leads to a change of attitude. The basic idea of any consistency theory, including the congruity theory, is that the human mind strives for harmony. Tannenbaum have proposed the congruity theory of attitudes which is similar to the balance theory. The negative effects of the lack of model diversity and the areas in which the interviewees would like to see increased diversity emerged during data.
The conceptual framework for this study was the role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders. Interpretations of the data were made from the perspective of selfimageproductimage congruity theory and selfconsciousness theory. The author investigated the conflicting predictions of role congruity theory and expectancy violation theory within the context of elite leadership. The size congruity effect entails that it is easier to. The congruity theory has been firstly advanced by charles osgood and percy tannebaum in their 1955 article the. This study was designed using the stimulusorganismresponse framework mehrabian and russell, 1974 and supported by self congruity theory sirgy, 1985 and minority stress theory meyer, 2003. Role congruity theory versus expectancy violation theory. This was a qualitative study using a multiplecase study methodology. Congruity theory is used as the basis for predictions made in this study. A role congruity study on news content and journalists perception of female and male leaders hong tien vu, tientsung lee, hue trong duong, and barbara barnett.
Theoretical issues the first problematic issuein the congruity theory is the reference point for a consumer is it brand image e. Some of the general assumptions underlying theories on the psychology of individual decisionmaking such as congruity theory are as follows. We test this conceptual framework in two experimental studies in samples of international fantasy game players, in which we manipulate congruity and. Congruity theory is a model of attitude change that describes some patterns of the relationship between two or more dimensions the principles underlying the congruity concept are very similar to its parent theory, heiders balance theory. Should an inconsistency become present, then the mind strives to turn that inconsistency back into a consistent structure. Self congruity theory is perfect to interpret the effect of selfimage congruence on consumer behavior sirgy, 1985. Are the processes underlying discrimination the same for. Coined by eagly and karau 2002, prejudice toward female leaders occurs because inconsistencies exist between the characteristics associated with the female.
Following social role theory eagly, 1987, role congruity theory predicts that role prescriptions are active only in contexts with cues that activate gender categorization. Apr 07, 20 psychology definition of congruity theory. This theory focuses on the changes in the evaluation of a source and a concept that are linked by an associative or dissociative assertion. Congruity theory is aimed directly at situations in which a source makes an assertion gives a message about an attitude object. Aside from this name change, the underlying theory is unchanged. Framed by social role and role congruity theories, this study explored the. Subjects were given a long list of people potential message sources, like president eisenhower or soviet leader kruchev and concepts communism, democracy and asked to report their attitude toward each one. It is the match between a brand image and an individuals selfconcept or the totality of the individual. Pdf destination personality, selfcongruity and loyalty. Conceptualization of place attachment, selfcongruity, and their. This incongruity creates barriers to women in organizations where they.
By seeking value congruity, the brand manager can help consumers to satisfy their identity needs by. In addition, the effect of emotional b rand attachment on the. Catalog of selected documents in psychology, 4, 27. Ambient advertising, a creative form of outofhome advertising that conveys direct and contextual messages by using and often altering existing elements of the environment in a way that surprises the target audience, appears to be a solution to the increasing. The principle of congruity in the analysis of international business. Coined by eagly and karau, prejudice toward female leaders occurs because inconsistencies exist between the characteristics associated with the female gender stereotype and those associated with the typical leadership. Overall results provide further empirical support to the selfimage congruity theory. The role of value congruity and consumer brand identification. Further, clark and teasdale 1985 indicated women recalled more material congruent to their mood state than men. Self congruity theory is important for extensive study that explains consumer selfimages. This theory states that how much change should be there in the attitudes towards the source and the concept so that incongruity is resolved. Two nodes that have fewer shared firstorder links than expected by chance are described as bipolar opposed.
This chapter begins by providing context and background for the study. The study deals with the effect that 1 extrinsic ethos, and 2 general susceptibility to persuasion have on a prejudiced or nonprejudiced persons degree of persuasibility to a onesided persuasive message presented by either a white or black source. The basic idea is that people prefer harmony, or consistency, in their thoughts. Social role theory and goal congruity social role theory eagly,1987. Selfcongruity theory in tourism selfcongruity refers to the degree of match or mismatch between an individuals perception of a brand or product and the perception they have of themselves sirgy, 1980. Jamal, ellen lust skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Clothing style preference of working women related to self. The study employed the use of both quantitative and qualitative methods to examine questions regarding the functions of evaluator attitudes, attributions, and role congruity expectations in leader performance evaluation processes.
Request pdf selfcongruity theory in consumer behavior. According to this theory, more congruity entails more positive consumer attitude to the brand and an increasing probability of brand. Runners completed an online survey that provided comprehensive information on their running behavior and their past and future apparel purchases. This integrative theory builds on social psychologists tradition of studying prejudice and stereotyping and industrialorganizational psychologists tradition of studying perceptions of managerial roles. Because of this, the unconscious bias that exists within individuals and at a societal level creates inconsistencies with the evaluation process. A role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders proposes that perceived incongruity between the female gender role and leadership roles leads to 2 forms of prejudice. Keywords selfcongruity theory, brand hate, functional incongruity. Congruity theory specifies that when an individual source of opinion praises or disparages some object, a receivers attitude. If selfcongruity theory holds in the context of tourism with destinations as brands, destination managers could position their destination to better match the market segments they seek to attract. Concinnitas in the architectural theory and practice of. Karau southern illinois university at carbondale a role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders proposes that perceived incongruity between the female gender role and leadership roles leads to 2 forms of prejudice. A theory stating a persons natural inclination to avoid pressure and seek harmony in the decision making process.
For those who are specifically interested in persuasion, congruity theory is much more focused than balance theory. Selfcongruity and volunteering research online uow. Some tenets of role congruity theory were supported in that male participants indicated that the agentic candidate was more competent when they were male than female and that the communal candidate was more competent when they were female than male. The purpose of this paper is to develop a theoretical basis for evaluating ambient advertising in relation to the schema. If fairness perceptions did differ significantly, the findings would support the notion that attitudes towards women in leadership roles were less positive than attitudes towards men even after controlling for sexist attitudes, thus supporting role congruity theory of. This paper investigates 1 if, and to what extent, selfcongruity theory is. Dec 06, 2010 congruity argument for god, from the great doctrines of the bible by evans notes. The purpose of this study was to investigate the perceived destination personality of bodrum a destination in turkey and the relationship among destination personality, selfcongruity and loyalty. The specific problem is how stereotypical views of female behavior affect women who aspire to highranking leadership roles in higher education. Congruity theory is one of the consistency theories of attitude change. Discuss congruity theory within the marketing management rm, im forums, part of the resolve your query get help and discuss projects category. Role congruity theory eagly and karau 2002 suggests that alignment between a groups characteristics and societys requirements of the groups social role results in congruity. Questionnaire is distributed personally on a paper format.
Role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders alice h. It bears a likeness to balance theory wherein it proposes that individuals are likely to possess an inclination for components in a mental system that are aligned with one another on an interior basis. Consequently, selfcongruity theory could be of great practical benefit to the tourism industry. A little history i revisit my journal of business research jbr article published in. Congruity is a stable state and incongruity is an unstable one. The relationship between selfcongruity and brand personality is an extensively studied aspect of self congruity theory and is an important concept for marketers to understand in order to get the most out of their brand. The self congruity theory is one of the most important theory that explains how important is and what role plays convergenceof consumer selfconcept and brand image in consumer behavior sirgy, 1982, 1986.
However, support for the mood congruity hypothesis for faster perception is mixed. Role congruity theory is grounded in social role theorys treat ment of the content of. Congruity definition and meaning collins english dictionary. Congruity theory was tested using a variety of hypothetical situations. Congruity theory explained when a group has their social roles recognized as being matched to their characteristics, then this will create a positive evaluation. The effect of teacher gender and gendered traits on. Bit has roots in three major mid20thcentury theories of cognitive affective consistency. Article information, pdf download for selfcongruity theory. The study deals with the effect that 1 extrinsic ethos, and 2 general susceptibility to persuasion have on a prejudiced or nonprejudiced persons degree of persuasibility to a onesided persuasive message. Congruity theory schema congruity theories propose that cues e.
Self congruity provides a comprehensive understanding of the selfconcept, integrating the many references to it in the. Thus, while role congruity theory would predict that female top leaders may be particularly susceptible to negative communal evaluations because they may be perceived as violating the prescriptive norms of their communal gender roles, it is possible that, instead, women top leaders would receive high ratings on their. Please, select more pdf files by clicking again on select pdf files. Congruity theory overview all consistency theories are about the relationship of the thoughts or ideas cognitions in a persons mind. The role of effortreward congruity ran kivetz incentives may simultaneously entice consumers and arouse reactance. Role congruity theory proposes that a group will be positively evaluated when its characteristics are recognized as aligning with that groups typical social roles. Expectations about the actual and ideal behavior of women and men to represent people os beliefs about women and men, our theory invokes the construct of gender role. Selfcongruity theory postulates that the more similar the two concepts, the higher the preference. Introduction efforts to understand individualtoindividual or teamtoteam interactions during the final alliance preformation phase are scarce.
Eagly and wood,2012 provides a broad framework for understanding how gender segregation into di. Thus this theory will help consumer to reveal self. Therefore, consumers purchase a brand as tools for selfexpression. In order to understand what congruity theory was trying to do, heiders balance theory will be described before moving on to explain osgood. The runners were categorized by the dualistic theory of passion, and their purchase intentions toward apparel brands for running were investigated from the self congruity perspective. An extension of congruity theory to multiple sources in web 2. The goal is to create consistency for each individual thought. Review of evidence for implicit consistency in social cognition.
1542 1600 178 1315 455 365 930 765 68 679 866 527 874 1551 547 568 1190 394 693 1576 715 1007 327 843 902 671 873 313 570 1267 1090 411 1169 405